BILLY BREMNER MEMORIAL JOIN OUR CAMPAIGN

Andy’s Sting In the Tale (08/11/2024 “Time to Remember, For Sure”

Date: 8th November 2024

(Photo:@Homesoffootball)

And Time for Football to Remember What We Used to Know But Have Forgotten

As a youngster I was surrounded in my community by unsung veterans of both World Wars including my dad and a yellowing photo of his dad at a training camp under canvas in an old album. Robert WilliamSmith is 3rd from the left.
What happened to those two generations before mine was never really talked about although my dad used to think Hollywood war films on our wee black and white telly or at the cinema were ridiculous and he did tell me his dad, gassed twice, and totally buggered for the rest of his gas-shortened life, (and by deed of parliament not bloody pensionable!) thought Earl Haig was a butcher and never considered the carnage to his men.
Ordinary men who were our collective grandads.
The wars however changed Britain in many ways for the good leaving a total un-acceptance of what had somehow socially and politically been acceptable before to ordinary folks.
When Britain was Great there were a lot of hungry and uneducated inhabitants and the wars certainly delivered generations who would not accept going back to the old rigid social structures and ways.
There was a huge and accelerating demand for real social change that was fanned by an education revolution and an awareness of the fact that women deserved full equality. Positive, if slow-burn legacies of the experience during and in the aftermath of both wars. Growing up in one of the many mid-50s post-war ‘Homes for Heroes’ sprawling housing estates, Dalneigh, on the banks of the Caledonian Canal my pals and I were football daft and used to go to the ‘Boys Club’, a white building in nearby Planefield Road to play football with equally football daft boys from schools all over the town.
A great and natural mixing pot making friendships for life.
I guess we started from primary 6 upwards for Thursday 5 a sides and then carried on with local leagues at under 15 and under 18.
Yes, there was a token weekly subscription for 5 a side in what was called the ‘concert hall’, but actual games playing for the Boys Club teams in strips, but no nets, on local municipal parks were free.
Free.
I progressed from the Junior Boys Club to the Boys Club Colts, The Boys Club Panthers, and the Juveniles locally and across Scotland.
We had real coaches too; Donnie Mackintosh was an ex Ranger and Stuart Gordon from Aberdeen was ex Highland League.
Great guys.
Group Of Boys Playing As Ballantyne Football Team 1950 - Edinburgh CollectedAdd that to the concurrent free schools football we all enjoyed against schools from Fort William to Banff and you understand what our game is missing today.

A huge hole caused by bit-by-bit erosion, a shocking lack of interest from and at the top and the shameful lack of any plan or commitment to fill the gaps that now gape wide and obvious.

Football should be free for all kids because it is good in every way for the nation and the game.

Why did we let what we had lapse to the token effort we have today?

And I’m not off-piste, so just to bring the story back to Remembrance Weekend.
The full name of the ‘Boys Club’ that provided so much to so many youngsters like me in Inverness was, ‘The Queens Own Cameron Highlanders War Memorial Boys Club’.

Queen's Own Cameron Highlanders War Memorial Youth ClubIt was a post wars, visionary gift and thank you to the youth and future youth of Inverness.
A huge statement of belief in the future and a small thank you and memorial to those ‘boys’ from the north who had made the ultimate sacrifice in both wars.

I didn’t used to even know much about or bother about November 11th but do remember reading and being amazed by a double paged strip in either The Victor or the Hotspur, (must reads to 10 year old boys back then), about what Hearts and Raith players did on the 25th of November 1914.

The Story – McCraes Battalion TrustWar had been declared in August and for some reason the Westminster Government had decided  football as ‘public entertainment’ should be granted ‘immunity’ to professional players so they could hide behind the convenient government screen.
Hearts were top of the league but disagreed with the protective blanket football was mostly hiding behind.
So, 16 Hearts players were joined by 7 from Raith Rovers and others, in good time, from Falkirk, Dunfermline, Hibs, St Bernards and East Fife and together enlisted for what became ‘McRae’s Battalion’. (Look it up)

 

Sadly 7 of the Hearts contingent including captain Tom Gracie never returned and each year what the team did, and the statement they made is celebrated solemnly and with hope and no triumphalism on the nearest Sunday to the 11th at the Haymarket War Memorial.

Jack Alexander wrote a magnificent book, Macrae’s Battalion, The Story of the 16th Royal Scots about it all.
A very readable insight into how it started, how it all unfolded, and it pulls no punches.
A masterpiece.
“The best football related book ever”.
I read it every couple of years or so and I’m glued to it again right now.
It should have been, and still could be a film or a series that recognises the sheer spirit to do the right thing while at the same time showing the futility of it all and the lack of commitment by many.
I particularly like an interchange when Peter Ross a beautifully described officer in McRae’s told Earl Haig, no less, in a field meeting after some sheer carnage the Battalion had been through what he thought of him.
The word butcher was used, and he wasn’t disciplined or punished apart from being sent into even more unattainable peril where he was killed by a German bullet.
I know my granddad and dad would have approved of his outburst, his to the point message, and now all those years on of the futility of it all and the sheer waste.
So 110 years on, thanks Queens Own Cameron Highlanders, Royal Scots, Notts and Derbyshire Regiment (AKA Sherwood Foresters), Royal Navy and all other serving organisation and units then and since.
There is nothing glorious about a generation of youngsters being decimated, anywhere.
Just belated thanks and sadness.


Andy’s Sting in the Tale


1. 20 Notes of Interest for ICT and Dilemmas to Come for the Beancounters

2. How ‘The Donald’ Aided by Andy Would Solve the Pyros Nonsense in a Day
3. Ex Hamilton Star Featured in Big Netflix Production
4. Angry Fans Against Media Bias
5. Saudi World Cup ‘Shoe-in’ Plan in Place
6. Meatloaf Song About Uefa Results
7. In Debt to the Government

 

1. No ‘Pre Pack’ is Concerning

Troubled Inverness Caledonian Thistle in talks with potential investor - BBC SportNaively I thought my club ICT would have had some kind of plan from within to reshape the club and even better to keep it close or even closer to the fans.
I don’t think that is an option anymore and the club looks to be really up ‘for sale’ with the only option a “Pretty-Please, Buy Me and Prettier-Please Don’t Asset Strip”. It looks to me now like BDO are holding a beancounters-auction because they have declared 20 notes of interest to be followed up.
Business is not always nice and all kinds of shenanigans can come out of this kind of process.
Rule number 1 is not all offers are benign or good natured.
Look what happened after 2012 in Glasgow when one club was stitched up by a pre-agreed and hidden deal between two particular rascals.
So BDO, the ICT fans deserve real due diligence by the beancounters and not stitch-ups.
I hope BDO can see the big picture and I personally can’t see beyond a plan that is based on a modest survival plan and an element of fan ownership with growth as the plan not the initial dogma.2. The Only Answer is Very, Very, Very, Strict Liability

Celtic v Aberdeen kick-off DELAYED after massive pyro display | The Scottish Sun
Uefa don’t tolerate Pyros so they don’t really happen in Uefa matches. Somehow the SPFL seems to avoid ‘Strict Liability’.
Why?
I’d say 2 or 3 clubs don’t want it and have effective total voting control as long as they stick together. My pal in Florida, ‘The Donald’ now a very, very, very powerful man would jump in with his size 14s and say ‘Pyros lead to match forfeiture’.
Next!

I don’t agree much with this man but that would stop it overnight.
So Andy agrees with ‘The Donald’.
Aberdeen reveal pre match Pittodrie pyro show as club ramp up atmosphere for crunch Rangers clash - Daily RecordIf you think flares are colourful and add atmosphere, then they do and they are, but that doesn’t make them acceptable or safe.
Here is an insight from two emails we received from an Aberdeen supporting SFSA member and a Celtic fan/ season book holder after witnessing a coordinated display that held last week’s flagship game up by 15 minutes.

“I was at the Aberdeen v Rangers match with my 8 year old son and the scenes make me question if I want to ever attend another.
Foul language, standing on seats aside, flairs ignited so close we could feel the heat, it was terrifying, for us and especially our son. My club, Aberdeen, bow to these idiots and do nothing and I’ve contacted them but they couldn’t care less.”

 

 

 

“I can’t be the only Celtic fan thoroughly fed up with the indulgence of these wee fannies. It’s particularly bad at away games”.
Guess who he was talking about?

 

The Donald’s Plan (as imagined but supported by Andy)
Strike 1 (home or away) A substantial fine and up a level to Strike 2 if repeated
Strike 2 A real and hurtful fine and up a level to Strike 3 next time.
Strike 3 Next game behind closed doors.
Strike 4 Game Forfeiture.
All fines paid into grass roots clubs/kids football development and no appeals.

3. When Kisses are Toxic
It's All Over: New documentary on the kiss that shook Spanish football - BBC SportIt’s on Netflix. The title is:
“It’s All Over: The Kiss That Changed Spanish Football”.
Luis Rubiales, ex Accies star man maybe planted the smacker but what went on before was long and systemic abuse and control of Spain’s women footballers”.
A must watch.

4.  Fans Angry on All Sides

When countries are in conflict one thing you can be sure of is  mug punters like us don’t get a balanced media insight into what is really happening.
And onlooking countries only get what their media editors want to tell them (and it’s always biased because that is life.)
But outside our own MSM we can read alternative views that make our right wing dominated press look quite partizan and one sided and it sadly pretends not to be but is.
Maybe we’re lucky compared to some other countries.
People in Russia only get told what the Putin machine in power wants to /allows them to think.
Israel citizens are told why what they are doing is their only option for survival and ‘anti-Zionism’ has long been conflated by generations of Israeli politicians with ‘antisemitism’ through their professional, powerful, coordinated media lobby when in reality they are two very different things.
So there is confusion abounding and sadly it always suits the perpetrators.France – Israël : Deux délégués de l'association « Stop Génocide » reçus mardi à la FFF Fifa are totally lacking leadership and have already demonstrated that there is one set of Fifa laws for some members and a different interpretation for others. There is growing outcry and this week the fans across Europe are showing what they really think.
French fans stormed the French FA to complain about the upcoming game with Israel at Stade de France.
Some fans don’t want it to happen.
PSG fans unveiled a huge ‘Free Palestine’ banner.
Dutch fans in Amsterdam openly supported the Palestinian people in the presence of Maccabi Fans and some severe intimidation and totally unacceptable violence occurred.
In balance, Maccabi fans do have previous against their own team’s Palestinian and Arab players and were said to have jeered the minutes silence for the Valencia floods and chanted racist slogans about Arabs and Palestine.

That’s what happens when real politics gets caught up in the media opportunities that football provides on a silver platter for both sides.

Maccabi fans ripping down ‘Free Palestinian’ banners maybe/probably don’t know how angry much of the outside world is about constant settlement grabs in Palestinian land and over 40,000 civilian deaths.

And finally as a predictable counterweight the Israeli FA shout at Fifa that Palestine FA boss Jabril Rajoub is using sports to promote terrorism and violence and I guess the usual anti semitism too.

And where are Fifa and Uefa with their declared rules and responsibilities?

I’d say too busy doing wee deals and feathering their own nests.
But what do I know

5. Fifa Not Fit for Purpose in Awarding World Cups

Gianni Infantino: Fifa president says player welfare 'remains a priority' - BBC Sport A couple of facts and a reaction by an ultra honest Fifa member.
No feedback from Scotland, as usual.
Fifa are conspiring with Saudi to ensure the ‘fit and proper’ human rights report, currently briefed and soon to be delivered by law firm Clifford Chance will pass with flying colours. (He who pays the piper and all that with cherry picking thrown in). Fifa are also said to be set to nod through the hosts for the 2030 (Spain, Portugal, Morocco, Uruguay, Argentina and Paraguay, and 2034 World cups (Saudi Arabia) with no discussion or vote.
‘It is vote ‘yes’ to both en bloc or ‘against’.
Norway’s Lise Klaveness said, “Fifa had real processes with skilled people at administrative level but now it is more distant from us members. The foundation of the voting was and should be the unanimous approval of the Fifa council.
It isn’t
Fifa have failed to explain what voting en bloc precisely means. Should members press yes or no?
We are also undertaking a consultation in Norway on the suitability of Saudi Arabia”.
I’ve said it many times.
Football needs honest and open administration that Fifa forgot about long, long ago.

6. Two Out of Three Ain’t Bad  

Hearts vs Heidenheim: UEFA Conference League - BBC Sport - BBC SportTwo great results for our biggest two clubs in Europe.
A long way to go but a banner result for Celtic against a top Bundesliga side with significantly more resource and better teams to play against each week, and another fine result for the seemingly unwanted and unloved Belgian and his blue team.
One of my pals, a lifelong and particularly well-informed bluenose said if the club were on a better financial footing he’d have been handed his jotters last week!
Not my club, so this is from a distance: Sometimes thoughtful perspective and football fans don’t mix well.
And sometimes maybe you need to ask more fundamental questions about why history seems to repeat itself.

And finally, at Tynie, a defeat but a strong and reassuring performance by Hearts who if they had put away earlier chances would have taken something from the game. Against a good team from a much more competitive and richer league.
Gorgie fans can be quick to get on the backs of the management the team and even the pigeons in the Wheatfield Stand if they are unhappy, but the fans standing ovation at the end was humbling and positive.

Well done guys.

7. The Money Was Never Free

Covid in Scotland: Director pay and bonus rules for SPFL clubs' loan11 of the top Scottish teams gratefully accepted covid loans during the pandemic.
Celtic were the only team to say ‘thanks but no thanks’.
The total loaned was £25.2 and the current tab is now just over £23.1M
The loans were on an interest free basis with quite generous repayment terms stretching to 2042.
The ’Divvy-Up’  was not our game’s finest day and in reality a bit of a self-interest buggers-muddle of a divvy-up if ever there was one which saw League 2 sides getting £100k, League 1 £150K and Championship sides £500K.
I wrote at the time that none of the divvying had anything to do with the actual business liabilities they were meant to support and Arbroath were said at the time to be huge winners while Thistle were huge losers.
Anyway the biggest current debt is Rangers still owing £2.88M and the smallest is Ross County at £1.04M.

 

 

I could have written about a dozen other stories, there is so much going on that never gets reported in the press.

That’s it for another week.

Feedback and wee stories always welcome.
Andy’s Album of the week

Visage: Visage

Visage (Visage album) - WikipediaI first encountered Midge Ure when he joined Salvation a really fine Glasgow based covers band in the early 70s.
They used to play regularly ever three or so months at the Queens Own Cameron Highlander’s War Memorial Boys Club, mentioned above in the intro, and the gigs always sold out.
The nights were live ‘dance to the music and mix’ events rather than concerts.
Many good times were enjoyed in the same wee hall that years before as kids we just wanted to play 5 a side football in.
There was indeed a lot of girl meets boy each time they played and Salvation were bloody good.
10 years later I was gifted the eponymous ‘Visage’ album, the first after Midge had joined up with Steve Strange.
I guess it was a post punk statement which wasn’t quite sure where it was headed but it is so ‘80s and so Newish Romantic that I’m loving the whole album and not just the 5 star ‘Fade to Grey’ track.
I haven’t played this album for a long time and it’s really nice to rediscover it.


Posted in: Andy’s Sting in the Tale, Latest News